The Book To Talk About (World Book Day 2008) ...
Today, as part of the proceedings leading up to World Book Day (March 6th, 2008), the committee announced the shortlist of the ten books deemed to be the major competitors for the title of "the book to talk about". You can find them here, along with the facility to register your own vote.
Guardian writers Richard Lea (who wrote the post on the Guardian's book blog) and Sam Jordison (who left a comment) are a bit flummoxed as to what it all means:
- Lea: 'It looks like a clear case of "ask a funny question, get a funny answer". What, after all, is a "book to talk about"? Is it really a book with "serious issues, character-led drama and often a splash of humour" as the committee suggests? Don't we just want to talk about good books? Whatever they might be ...'
Jordison: 'I don't quite get it either, and am mildly miffed that the book I voted for (The Red Men) didn't get through to the last ten... I also have a slight suspicion that the authors most likely to get through in an internet poll like this are the ones most able to cajole their friends into voting for them. Then again, it's interesting/ gratifying to see a list so well represented by small presses and free of the usual suspects... Plus, I've been meaning to read Lint for a while, and I guess this is another good spur/reminder... So, er, in a roundabout way, I suppose I'm saying that the shortlist might well be a Good Thing.'
Lea also notes that the longlist was 'assembled by "industry experts"; clearly wondering what that means in reality and fact (World Book Day does not seem to be transparent in this).
But, well hell, let's have some fun with what appears to be, on the face of it, a Brownies' event bran tub: anything gets chucked in and anything can come out. Yes, it's an odd list, but so be it. I'd like to think that those who have voted thus far, and left comments are mainly readers, so it makes it a popular readers' vote. That shortlist of ten might even be the top ten for readers' groups around the UK in finding the best they can imagine to "talk about" at their meetings.
Looking at that top ten shortlist, which now requires another round of reader voting, I am familiar with two names. More on one of these later, as the crime genre is involved. (Well, this is a crime fiction site, in the main.) But, "Death of a Murderer" by Rupert Thomson also caught my eye. Was it crime fiction? When I read the page I was reminded of an interview I heard last year on the now sadly passed-into-the-digital-ether Oneword Radio DAB station, with the author and "Between The Lines" presenter Paul Blezard. At the time, my interest was tempted; but this remains for another day or so's reading. Comments on World Book Day are mixed, but I still have some fascination in seeking out this book which does not mention the name of Myra Hindley, but is clearly based on her, as the author openly admitted in that interview. This was a case that shocked a nation beyond belief. I believe that every mother of a young child at that time, however many miles away, was led to be over-protective to a degree. However, the reaction of innocents can never detract from the immense and immeasurable loss that has no empathetic description for those who suffered at the hands of Brady and Hindley. Approx. twenty years later, I thought about reading the transcript of the case in the Law Library when at university. I never had the guts to do it.
Now onto the crime genre feature in this feast from World Book Day ...
Recent Comments