(Apologies in advance for some blurry pics and the assorted shapes for the pics.)
The debate was "Who writes the best crime fiction? The US or the UK?" For the US we had, below from the left, Harlan Coben (tell everyone he was there) and Lee Child (born in Birmingham in the UK, before he escaped to the US and started his brilliant "Jack Reacher" career in crime fiction). In the middle is Mark Lawson from the BBC, chairing, umpiring and applying scores at his discretion (proving he was a tough nut to crack in respect of the UK's position).
Moving on, for the UK it was Val McDermid (very happy to wear the Union Jack) and Mark Billingham (the multi-talented performer in whose company there is never a dull moment).
At some point we were told that on this occasion the UK would indeed include Scotland...
Opening arguments from both sides were given five minutes each and Val McD kicked off, certainly filling her five minutes with a well researched proposal as to why the UK led the field. Even Edgar Allen Poe was educated in the UK before moving back to the US and writing crime fiction, didn't you know? The UK simply has so much history as a well established country - the parent of all, including crime fiction, if you like; whereas the US may be considered to be still in nappies (diapers). (My words, not hers - it's a summary for you to get the drift...)
Lee Child came back later with a denigration of all things "cosy" (as he saw it) in the UK, picking on one of the UK's most respected and read crime fiction authors, honoured and now seen as national treasure - Ruth Rendell. OK, we had rain and floods and more rain, during the weekend. But, according to Lee Child, a Ruth Rendell suspense plot revolves around: Will it rain? How long will it rain? Is it still raining? Do I need to take my umbrella? Will the rain cause damp in the kitchen? Or arguments to that effect.
Where Harlan Coben took up the mantle with great aplomb, Mark Billingham was sound with his rejoinder. And vitriolic. I'm not sure when he got to the point of indicating that the Scots could "...bugger off and take the Welsh..." with them, but that's English jealousy for you. (The Midlands got the Welsh Elan Valley water pretty cheap for years, but now Wales has its own WAG. No, nothing to do with football. On this occasion it's the Welsh Assembly Government. And some of us Welshies do love the English too, you know!)
Then after the main arguments, a selection of "team members" added their own thoughts to the proceedings and the scoring, with up to a minute to pour forth...
Recent Comments