Warning: spoilers; if you have not seen the full series through to completion.
A gripping and suspenseful series, well worth the watch, but not as good as last year's. The suspense around this series revolved around one thing alone: would Juliet speak; would she open up; would she speak the truth of her marriage; and if so, when and would it save her?
Certain aspects were obvious from the start and I experienced no surprises in the plot, unlike last year's. There were also some loose ends that could have been covered to greater dramatic effect, e.g. why did DI Sexton behave as he did? There must have been a reason above copper training and "towing the line" for such a reaction to this case and the impending fall out with his wife. Why did it take so long for DCI Faber to realise the meaning of a piece of CCTV footage and pass it to the defence? Why, oh why was the charged, pregnant and with a history of depression never seen in the care of a psychiatrist? Her daughter was and we do not live in Victorian times.
The denouement was also as expected, if you had your thinking cap on. The judge was always going to be a bastard, protecting those of his own profession as we saw the glimpse in earlier episodes. However, balancing reality and drama, I am sure there are plenty of women out there who fall foul in such cases, making this a realistic drama. But, and it's a big but, surely they'd also appeal? Therefore, why not include that in the drama? The end might have been a good place to stop for drama and not satisfactory but it didn't tell the whole story. Poignant, musical-accompanied long stills could have been dumped for more plot and further realism.
All that said, series one was one for the boys and I enjoyed it greatly, though it rattled my core, as well it should have, as well as yours. Series two was one for the female persuasion and aimed at them/us, I suspect. Above all, the suspense was emotional and based on female abuse. What a wonderful cast in this series: Sophie Okonedo was excellent as a dignified, jaw-strutting solicitor wanting the truth and believing it would come out; Alice Sykes was excellent as the confused daughter; Zoe Telford was also excellent as the barrister with more than one need to win. Nadine Marshall was sometimes forefront and sometimes background in her role, but she played every aspect to perfection.
Lastly, Maxine Peake. What an outstanding acting performance. She made Juliet very real. You wanted to slap her in the face to bring her back to actual reality in Juliet's world on times, experiencing the frustration of disclosure, honour and truth, over shame. I was in tears a few times during this series and so much so in its closing scenes. Ms Peake, you were remarkable. I expect to see you on the BAFTA shortlist for best Actress (or is it now a politically correct best Actor?) next year.
In conclusion: plot predictive and perhaps shallow at the end of the day, but wonderful cast and excellent acting. If it had been on ITV, Kleenex would have been an appropriate sponsor. Don't miss it & see it here on iplayer.
Recent Comments